Algorithms shouldn’t foster price discrimination

Online shopping and e-commerce technology concept, shopper using computer laptop to input order with trolley credit card delivery truck. istock photo for BL | Photo Credit: ipuwadol
Before the onset of MRP rule, shopkeepers looked at customers and decided how much to charge. Now technology has started it again and without even looking at your face. It looks at your browsing history, location, shopping habits, phone brand, income proxies and perhaps even your urgency.
This algorithmic pricing ensures that two people buying exactly the same item need not pay exactly the same price. For businesses, it is marketing genius. For consumers, it is an expensive relationship with AI. Service businesses brought some legitimacy to this. Airlines, hotels and cab aggregators have used dynamic pricing for years. When demand rises, availability becomes scarce, and prices move accordingly. One can complain about it, but at least the algorithm isn’t offended by one’s bank balance.
But in surveillance pricing, the price can change depending on who you are. Two customers looking at the same product, at the same time, could see different prices because an algorithm believes one is more willing, or more capable, of paying. You may get a discount for loyalty but your affluence may earn you a penalty. But your desperation could be the most costly item in your digital profile.
When a colleague had repeatedly searched for the cheapest ticket to Mumbai for a family emergency, she was charged more for the same flight as her friend who had casually browsed in Chrome. The algorithm concluded that the colleague had little choice but to buy, offered no compassion.
The same possibilities extend to hotel bookings, online retail, food delivery, insurance and ride-hailing. A customer who repeatedly checks into a premium hotel may be offered a different price from someone who has never stayed there. Are businesses competing to offer the best price or becoming increasingly efficient at discovering the maximum price a customer can be persuaded to pay?
Consumer protection
India’s e-commerce has accelerated much faster than the consumer protection architecture, especially in matching the platform sophistication. The Consumer Protection Act protects against misleading ads and unfair trade practices. The Central Consumer Protection Authority’s 2023 guidelines on dark patterns recognise practices such as drip pricing, bait-and-switch and false urgency. In 2025, the government also advised e-commerce platforms to conduct self-audits and eliminate such practices. The DPDP framework covers how companies collect and use personal information.
More recently, the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Amendment Rules, 2026 have signalled a stronger regulatory approach to online marketplaces. Coming into effect on January 1, 2027, they tighten requirements around discount claims, platform conduct and transparency. Yet there is no specific blanket prohibition on personalised algorithmic pricing. The law may catch deceptive or unfair practices, but the question of whether two consumers should be charged different prices for the same product purely because of their personal data needs serious attention..
Consider the implications. If an e-commerce platform advertises a 40 per cent discount, is that a genuine discount available to everyone, or a carefully engineered number offered to customers who are more likely to convert? If a cab aggregator charges more because demand has surged, that is one thing. If it charges more because it believes a passenger has no alternative, that is quite another.
Not every targeted discount is discrimination. Loyalty programmes, student concessions and transparent promotional offers can benefit consumers. The problem begins when the criteria are hidden, the price differences are unexplained and personal data becomes a tool for extracting more money.
Coordinated pricing
A digitally savvy consumer might compare prices, clear browsing histories, use different devices or wait for better offers. Crores of others will end up paying whatever appears on their screens. Worse, they won’t have any idea that the person sitting next to them paid less. Price discrimination becomes invisible. There is also a competition concern. If several competing businesses rely on similar third-party pricing tools, regulators must examine whether these systems are merely responding to market conditions or creating opportunities for coordinated pricing behaviour. Technology should not be allowed to mask practices that would violate MRTP rules.
India needs a clear framework for algorithmic pricing. Platforms should disclose when personal data materially influences the price offered to an individual. Regulators should distinguish legitimate demand-based dynamic pricing from surveillance-based price discrimination. Companies must maintain auditable records of pricing decisions, data inputs and third-party algorithms.
There should also be a simple consumer right: the ability to know why the price on one screen differs from the price on another.
Businesses will understandably argue that such restrictions could hurt innovation. That is a familiar argument whenever regulation threatens a profitable or “easy” business model. No way India can afford to accept this argument like they do with most other policies when pushed back by powerful business lobbies. Board governance reforms are stagnant because of this. No innovation should be at the expense of customers surrendering their privacy, bargaining power and right to fair treatment at the checkout counter.
Algorithms have become remarkably good at reading human beings, even when human beings have no idea they are being read. Shoshana Zuboff’s critique of surveillance capitalism raises a more disturbing question: when companies know our habits, weaknesses and vulnerabilities, do they simply serve us better, or acquire the power to manipulate what we buy and what we pay?
Marketers used to say that the customer is king. Now the algorithm has staged a palace coup. It knows when you are desperate, when you are impulsive and when your credit card is having a weak moment. Isn’t there something called “fairness” anywhere?
Muneer is a Fortune-500 advisor, start-up investor and co-founder of the non-profit Medici Institute for Innovation
Published on November 20, 2026
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)